Written by Hi, it’s Dre Griggs with Obsidian Wisdom. Today, we’re answering the question: How do I choose between a large lump sum or a pension for retirement? If you’re considering this choice, you’re probably a public sector employee. Only about a fifth of people working have access to a pension, and the majority of those are in the public sector. You might work in the military, as a police officer, firefighter, teacher, or for a government department.
Control vs. Guaranteed Income
The first consideration is whether you want control or guaranteed income. If you prefer control, where you can choose your investments and maximize returns, a large lump sum might be right for you. If you prefer a guaranteed income, where you have a set monthly amount, then a pension might be the better choice.
With a pension, you have a set floor of income, such as $2,000 a month, which can provide stability. Add Social Security, and you might have around $4,000 a month in retirement. This setup can make you feel secure and comfortable. However, you need to trust that the company or government providing the pension will be around for the long haul.
Inflation and Investment Risk
The second consideration is inflation and investment risk. All retirement income forms carry some risk. Inflation risk means your purchasing power decreases over time. For instance, $100 today might only be worth $50 in 20 years due to inflation.
If your pension doesn’t adjust for inflation, you might struggle to maintain your lifestyle as prices rise. On the other hand, choosing a large lump sum involves investment risk. You’ll need to invest wisely to ensure your money lasts, which requires a solid withdrawal strategy and market awareness.
Health and Life Expectancy
Your health and life expectancy are crucial when choosing between a lump sum and a pension. If you expect to live a long life, a pension might be more beneficial as it provides a steady income. If your family has a history of long life spans, you might prefer the stability of a pension.
Conversely, if you have health concerns or a shorter life expectancy, a lump sum might make more sense. This way, you can control how your money is used and ensure it benefits your loved ones.
Estate Planning
Estate planning is another important factor. If leaving a financial legacy to your children or charity is a priority, a lump sum gives you more control. You can manage how the money is distributed and ensure your wishes are followed.
With a pension, unless you choose an option with survivorship benefits, the money stops when you do. This can limit the amount you leave behind.
Tax Considerations
Finally, consider the tax implications. Taking a large lump sum all at once can push you into a higher tax bracket, resulting in a hefty tax bill. Rolling the money into an IRA can mitigate this, allowing you to withdraw funds gradually and potentially lower your tax liability.
With a pension, you’re only taxed on the monthly income you receive, which can help keep you in a lower tax bracket. This can make managing your tax burden easier.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a large lump sum and a pension depends on your personal situation, goals, and comfort with risk. Both options can work well, but the right choice for you will depend on your financial stability, health, estate planning desires, and tax considerations.
Until next time, stay safe and enjoy life.
Image from: Freepik.com